When selecting a toilet bowl for your home, one of the most important considerations is its shape. Homeowners often choose between round and elongated toilet bowls, but which one is the better option? While both have their own advantages, the right choice depends on factors such as space, comfort, and aesthetics.
In Singapore, where bathrooms tend to be more compact, choosing the right toilet bowl can have a significant impact on functionality and comfort. This guide will break down the differences between round and elongated toilet bowls, their pros and cons, and which one might be the best fit for your needs.
Understanding the Difference Between Round and Elongated Toilet Bowls
The primary distinction between these two types of toilet bowls lies in their shape and dimensions:
- Round Toilet Bowls: Typically shorter in length, around 40 cm to 43 cm (16 to 17 inches) from the seat bolts to the front of the bowl.
- Elongated Toilet Bowls: Usually longer, measuring around 46 cm to 48 cm (18 to 19 inches) from the seat bolts to the front.
Both options come in various designs and flushing systems, but their fundamental shape affects the overall experience for users.
Advantages of Round Toilet Bowls
Space-Saving for Small Bathrooms
- In Singapore, many HDB flats and condominiums have compact bathrooms. Round toilet bowls take up less space, making them ideal for smaller layouts.
- If you have a powder room or a secondary bathroom, a round toilet bowl helps maximise floor space.
Budget-Friendly
- Round toilet bowls are often more affordable than elongated models. If you’re looking for a cost-effective option, a round toilet bowl may be the better choice.
Child-Friendly
- For households with young children, round toilet bowls can be easier to use. The smaller seat size is often more comfortable for toddlers transitioning from potty training.
Disadvantages of Round Toilet Bowls
Less Comfortable for Adults
- Some users, especially taller individuals, find round toilet bowls less comfortable because they provide less seating space.
Outdated Look
- In modern bathrooms, elongated toilet bowls are often preferred for their sleek, contemporary design. A round toilet bowl may not complement a high-end or minimalist bathroom aesthetic.
Advantages of Elongated Toilet Bowls
More Comfortable Seating
- The extra length provides better thigh support, making elongated toilet bowls more comfortable for adults and taller individuals.
- If comfort is a priority, this option is often recommended.
Easier to Maintain and Clean
- Elongated toilet bowls have a larger opening, making it easier to clean and maintain compared to round bowls.
- Less splashing and mess means better hygiene over time.
Sleek and Modern Design
- Many luxury and smart toilet bowls in Singapore come in an elongated shape. This option is visually appealing and suits modern and high-end bathroom designs.
Disadvantages of Elongated Toilet Bowls
Takes Up More Space
- In smaller bathrooms, an elongated toilet bowl may feel bulky and reduce available space for movement.
- It is crucial to measure your bathroom dimensions before selecting an elongated model.
Slightly More Expensive
- Compared to round toilet bowls, elongated models tend to be more costly due to their design and materials.
Which Toilet Bowl is Best for Your Singapore Home?
The best choice depends on your bathroom space, budget, and comfort preference. Here are key considerations to help you decide:
1. Consider Your Bathroom Space
- For smaller bathrooms: A round toilet bowl is ideal, as it takes up less space and allows better movement.
- For larger bathrooms: An elongated toilet bowl offers better aesthetics and comfort.
2. Think About Who Will Be Using It
- For families with children: A round toilet bowl is easier for kids to use.
- For adults who prioritise comfort: An elongated toilet bowl is generally more ergonomic.
3. Aesthetics and Modern Features
- If you prefer a contemporary look, an elongated toilet bowl is more stylish and complements smart toilet features.
- If you are renovating an older HDB flat or have a minimalist bathroom design, consider whether a round or elongated model fits your aesthetic.
Installation and Maintenance Considerations
Regardless of which type you choose, proper installation and maintenance are essential for ensuring longevity and functionality.
- Professional Installation:
- If you’re unsure about measurements, consult a toilet bowl installation specialist in Singapore.
- Some homeowners opt for smart toilet bowls, which are often elongated and require additional plumbing considerations.
- Regular Cleaning:
- Both round and elongated toilet bowls require proper maintenance to prevent odours and stains.
- Water Efficiency:
- Consider a dual-flush toilet bowl to save on water bills.
- The Public Utilities Board (PUB) in Singapore encourages the use of water-efficient toilet bowls under the Water Efficiency Labelling Scheme (WELS).
Conclusion
Ultimately, when you are considering purchasing a toilet bowl in Singapore, the choice between a round and elongated toilet bowl depends on your bathroom size, comfort needs, and budget. If you have a compact bathroom, a round model may be better suited. However, if comfort and aesthetics matter most, an elongated toilet bowl is worth considering.
